Many people get sticker shock when they initially look into Disney Cruise Line and wonder, what on earth am I paying this much money for?!? Having been on 11 Disney Cruises and now being a proud Platinum member and also having sailed Royal Caribbean I think I might be able to answer that question a little better than before.
PROS
Ship Size. Disney Cruise Line has smaller ships and therefore less people on board, making the experience a bit more personal than some of the mega-liners other lines have.
Rotational Dining. DCL has a great dining experience and has definitely stepped up their game in the food department, the last few cruises we’ve been on we’ve had great meals and we aren’t afraid to send back the meals we don’t think are perfect anymore, always ask for a new meal if you don’t like what you get. Also the fact that you and your wait staff go to three different dining locations throughout the cruise is a great way to experience different cuisine and see all three wonderful dining rooms. Palo is also a great option and I’ve heard Remy is as well.
Family Activities and Kids Clubs. Disney is known for entertaining and they have some of the best entertainment around. The kids clubs are awesome, the only downside is adults aren’t allowed! (I’m so jealous I was never cruising when I was younger so I could play in those awesome kids spaces!). Shore excursions include lots of options for families and for younger children.
Minimal Smoking. There are only a few areas aboard that smoking is allowed, so that makes the ship a lot more enjoyable from my perspective.
Castaway Cay. The private island alone is a reason to go sail with DCL. You must experience it for yourself, it is an amazing place and the adult only beach area is fabulous.
Broadway style theater shows. The entertainment is fantastic, each ship has a slightly different set of Broadway quality theater shows as well as great entertainers that come aboard that vary. (However we have seen the same magician and ventriloquist a few times).
Friendliness. The cast members aboard are always especially friendly and willing to help you in whatever way they can. Many crew members are familiar and sometimes recognize you from cruise to cruise, makes you feel at home!
Adult areas. The adult areas, especially on the new ships are fantastic. Lots of fun new bars and adult pool areas make the Disney ship a retreat for adults where they don’t have to deal with screaming kids.
Disney Characters. On no other cruise line do you get to meet and greet with Mickey and friends!
Cleanliness. Disney is determined to keep their ships clean and their customers healthy and happy, we’ve been happy with the way the ship is maintained and the crew members are always passing out sanitizing wipes before meals.
Cons
Price. Disney Cruise Line is way more expensive than most lines, and isn’t all inclusive. However there is unlimited soda from the fountains on the top decks and all regular dining is included, but not wine or beer or specialty meals at Palo and Remy.
Kids. If you don’t like a lot of children, you might be turned off Disney. The adults only areas are great places to get away from kids and honestly we’ve never had problems with them (they are usually contained pretty well by the kids spaces.)
Limited Itineraries. With only 4 ships there are only so many destinations Disney can go to, which is a factor to consider.
Discounts. It is rare for Disney to discount cruises, and if they do they are usually for very last minute sailings. The best way to get a “discount” is to rebook on board for 10% off your next voyage.
Everything is Disney. If you don’t like hearing Disney music playing in the halls at all hours or are capable of eventually tuning it out you may get sick of all that excess Disney cheer that floats around. However if you don’t mind, it really is a great way to travel with class.
Limited “extras”. The new Royal Caribbean ships have a robotic bar and a giant pod that lifts you high into the sky, a surfing simulator and rock climbing walls. Disney has none of that, but they do have great cooking classes and mixology and other tasting classes.
Whichever cruise line you choose be sure to do your research on what all is included and what the ship has for amenities.